If SIPs Make Such a Good Wall, Why Is My Builder Still Ordering Studs?

Picture a builder at his desk on a Thursday afternoon. He has two prices in front of him for the same little ranch house. One came from the lumberyard where he’s had an account for twenty years. The other came from a company that can deliver the exterior walls cut to fit, with the insulation already in them. He likes the second idea. Then he picks up the phone and calls his framer.

“How much comes off your price if the outside walls show up already built?”

There’s a pause. The framer still has the interior partitions to build. He wants to know how big the panels are, who’s unloading them, and whether the manufacturer sends somebody out on the first job. He’ll get back to him Monday. Meanwhile, the lumberyard salesman knows where to drop the first load and which driveway to leave open so the neighbor can get to work.

Somewhere in that ordinary Thursday afternoon is an explanation for why structural insulated panels, or SIPs, trace their roots to the 1930s and are still a novelty to the fellow building the house down the street.

A pretty clever sandwich

Take two sheets of oriented strand board, put a rigid insulating foam core between them, and bond the whole thing together under controlled conditions. The bond makes the three pieces work together. Think of a long shelf with a load on it. Move its two faces farther apart and hold them in position, and you’ve improved its ability to resist bending. In a SIP, the core helps do that job while also insulating the building.

Expanded polystyrene is a common core. Other systems use extruded polystyrene or polyurethane. OSB is the facing most residential builders will recognize, although specialty panels come with metal or cement-based facings. Those distinctions matter when you order. Two panels can look much the same leaning against a shop wall and have different capacities, connections, and insulation values.

A manufacturer can turn the drawings into numbered wall, roof, or floor panels, complete with specified openings. Stand a wall panel in place, and a good share of the framing, sheathing, and insulation work is already there. Fewer studs interrupt the insulation. With well-sealed joints, the crew can deliver a tight shell. Anybody who has ever tried to insulate the narrow space beside a window header on a windy January afternoon can appreciate the attraction.

The price comparison that gets the panel thrown out

If I owned that panel company, I’d want to see the builder’s estimating sheet. I’d bet there’s a line for framing lumber, another for sheathing, a labor allowance from the framer, and an insulation bid tucked away a page or two later. Now along comes my panel quote. Which line does he put it on?

Put it alongside the lumber package and my wall looks mighty expensive. Credit me with the entire insulation contract, and suddenly I look like a genius, right up until somebody remembers the attic still needs insulation. The builder needs two prices for the same finished scope of work. Freight belongs in there. So do lifting equipment, installation help, and the time somebody spends turning architectural drawings into an approved panel order.

Then there’s the schedule. Getting under roof three days earlier has real value if it gets the electrician in three days earlier. If he’s booked through the end of the month, the builder has bought a dry place to wait. That may be worth something, especially in February, but I’d hesitate to put three days of savings in the bank.

The homeowner looks at a different set of numbers. A comfortable house with lower heating and cooling bills can pay dividends for years. How much depends on the climate, the rest of the envelope, the equipment, and what the house would otherwise have been built with. The builder has to write the check this month. The family gets the utility bills. Both can understand the benefits perfectly and still have quite different opinions about the price.

Who signed off on the kitchen window?

Offsite construction has a way of exposing decisions everybody thought somebody else had made. Imagine the buyer walks her framed kitchen with the builder and asks if the window over the sink could slide six inches to the left. With a conventional crew on site, the builder can ask what it will take and get an answer over coffee. With a panel already cut, the superintendent has a different phone call to make. Somebody has to check the change against the panel design, develop a detail, and decide who pays for it.

Now put yourself in the shoes of the electrician who missed the preconstruction meeting, or the inspector seeing this particular system for the first time. Each has reasonable questions. If they get answered while the drawings are open, the job can move along nicely. If the first conversation takes place beside a truck waiting to unload, the superintendent is likely to remember that job for quite a while.

Distance compounds the problem. The lumberyard can put a forgotten item on tomorrow’s truck. A replacement panel coming from two states away is another proposition. A local installer who knows the system and a manufacturer who picks up the phone can influence a purchasing decision more than another point of advertised R-value.

Where a panel earns its ride

One of the more interesting places to think about this is a polar research station. Imagine the cost of getting a carpenter, tools, and materials to a remote site, then losing a working day to the weather. Suddenly a factory-cut, insulated panel that does several jobs and arrives ready to assemble looks like a bargain even after a very expensive ride. The economics of that research station help explain why the same sales pitch can fall flat on a subdivision five minutes from the lumberyard.

At the other end of the scale, consider a tiny-home shop building its tenth copy of a popular model. The owner knows where the windows go. The electrician knows where the wiring runs. A correction made on the first unit can carry through the next nine. A shop building volumetric modules can ask much the same question. If panels free up people at the station that’s holding up production, the plant manager has something worth measuring. If they simply get the walls to an already backed-up station sooner, he’s bought himself a different place to stack them.

There’s room for imagination here, too. An architect can use a series of flat panels to build a faceted roof that reads as a curve. A designer pursuing Passive House performance can use thick panels to carry insulation up the walls and across the roof. In both cases, the interesting work is at the joints. Sooner or later, somebody has to draw how those pieces meet, and somebody in work boots has to be able to reach the seam and seal it.

Gary’s Observation

Gary Fleisher, modcoach@gmail.com

If I were trying to sell more SIPs, I’d ask a local builder to bring me the plan he expects to build three times next year. Then I’d ask him to bring his framer. Between the three of us, we ought to be able to work out what comes off the lumber order, what stays in the labor bid, who unloads the truck, and what happens if panel number seven arrives damaged. I’d also want the superintendent to keep his hours on that first house. He’s the one most likely to know what we forgot.

A tighter energy budget or one more retirement on the framing crew may get that builder to return the panel salesman’s call. What earns the second order is a Thursday afternoon six months later when he reaches for the phone, asks his framer about doing another SIP house, and hears, “Sure. Just have them load the kitchen wall last this time. We need it first.”

Before You Cut the Ribbon, Who Will Order the Second House?

I can usually tell when a new modular factory is about to open. Somebody sends me a drone video. The concrete shines, the line stretches into the distance, and three people in brand-new hard hats study something just outside the frame. I always hope one of them is looking at a purchase order.

Then comes the ribbon cutting. The county commissioners get their picture, the owner says a few words about affordable housing, and somebody asks what kind of customer the factory hopes to attract. “We’re ready to build for anyone,” the owner says. Somewhere behind him stands the poor soul who has to estimate whatever comes through the door on Monday.

If you’re a Gen X or Millennial owner putting your name and possibly your house behind a modular startup, here’s the question I’d ask before somebody orders those big scissors. Who do you expect to buy the second house, and what has to happen on the first one for them to call you again? Work backward from that phone call, and you’ve got the beginnings of a marketing plan.

Your Factory’s Most Expensive Problem May Be Waiting for an Answer

A worker notices something wrong with a module at 8:15 Monday morning. The supervisor hears about it before the first break. By lunch, somebody has taken a picture and sent an email. Tuesday morning, engineering asks which drawing revision the crew was using. Tuesday afternoon, purchasing gets involved.

By Wednesday, the factory has an answer.

Unfortunately, it also has several more modules with the same problem.

This is a hypothetical example, but it describes a management failure worth examining in every offsite business. The worker found the problem early. The company allowed the problem to grow while deciding what to do about it.

Owners spend considerable time asking how to make people work faster. They ought to spend some of that time asking how long their employees wait for answers.

BOXABL’s Next Challenge: Helping Buyers Pay for the Home

Building a home in a factory is only part of getting someone into it. Before a production slot becomes a delivery date, somebody has to answer a less exciting question: How will the customer pay for the entire project?

BOXABL is taking a step toward addressing that question. In a November 10 announcement distributed through PR Newswire, the company said it signed a nonbinding letter of intent with Warp Speed Holdings to establish a mortgage lending joint venture. The companies are targeting an early 2027 launch, subject to final agreements and regulatory requirements.

The proposed platform would bring financing into the purchase process earlier. Planned offerings include construction loans, construction-to-permanent financing and rate buydowns. Depending on the product, financing could cover land, site improvements, manufacturing, delivery, installation and the permanent mortgage. Potential customers include homeowners, investors, builders and developers. 

That is a meaningful list. For a prospective buyer, the factory price is one number. The amount required to turn a piece of property into a finished, usable home can be a very different conversation.

A Woman’s Touch in Construction

Fresh Eyes on Modular By Jorie Wisnefski

I never expected to find myself in the construction industry. It was never on my radar.

I started my career as a teacher because it suited my personality. I like helping and working with people, and I don't regret that career choice, but it was also a path I was kind of expected to take.

Construction was something my husband Mike understood. He’s the wood nerd who sees a truck going down the highway and marvels at the load of lumber it’s carrying. I used to ignore him. Now I pull out my phone to take pictures.

I get it.

Once you learn a little about how things are made and what it takes to turn a building from an idea into a finished product, it's hard not to get interested. And the people you meet along the way make it even more worthwhile.

That's something I appreciate about this industry. It's a relationship business, and I've been fortunate to meet some remarkable women along the way.

Six Modules Came Off the Line. When Can We Bill for Them?

Imagine it’s Thursday afternoon at a modular factory. The production manager tells the owner that all six modules in the first batch came off the line on schedule. The controller has a question. “Can I send the invoice today?” Five modules have signed inspection reports. Somebody remembers seeing the plumber in the sixth one that morning. Nobody in the room knows whether he finished the pressure test.

I’d want that question answered before everyone went home. Under this particular contract, the customer owes a progress payment once all six modules pass inspection. One open test can hold up the draw on a whole batch. And if the lender reviews payment requests on Friday mornings, an hour spent finding the answer on Thursday could cost the factory a week.

That little scene is hypothetical, but it explains why, if I ran a modular company, the controller would have a seat at my production meeting. It also explains where I’d spend my first dollar on factory tracking technology.

Before I promise a slot on the line

What Would You Do to Get a 100-Module Order From a New Customer?

Suppose a developer calls three modular factory owners on a Monday morning. He needs 100 modules and wants to know who can build them. The first owner pulls up the production schedule and asks, “When will the first foundation be ready?” The second asks, “Is this one building, or is it the first of several?” The third covers the phone and tells the sales manager, “Whatever it takes, don’t let this guy get away.”

If you work in sales, you might enjoy working for that third owner. If you handle payroll, you probably have a few more questions.

I can think of nine attitudes that show up in decisions like this. An owner can hold several at once and, depending on how empty next month’s production schedule looks, change attitudes before lunch. Three lend themselves to steady growth. Three can help a factory grow quickly. The last three can put a good operation in real trouble.

BOXABL Went Public. Now Comes the Hard Part.

BOXABL seems quieter these days. For a company that attracted so much attention around folding homes and the possibility of changing how housing gets built, that quieter profile invites a reasonable question: What is actually happening inside the business?

There is activity. Project announcements, a large potential purchase agreement, changes in financial leadership, and another mechanism for raising capital. What remains difficult to establish from the information reviewed is whether those developments are producing a dependable flow of completed, revenue-generating deliveries.